I've just come back from a week at "Testfest," where the Automobile Journalists Association of Canada (AJAC) tests vehicles to name the Car of the Year and Utility Vehicle of the Year winners, both in their categories - the winners already announced - and the overall champions, which will be named next February at the Toronto Auto Show. It was almost a clean sweep by the Koreans and Germans this year.
Not all vehicles are tested. To be eligible, a vehicle must be all-new or substantially changed, which is why your favorite might not be on the list. Journalists were assigned to specific categories - I had three to do - and could drive and vote in others, provided they drove all of them. Cars go on a track, SUVs on an off-road loop, and all get driven on the street and highway. We all drove the category winners on the final day. Here's what won and my thoughts on the ones I drove:
Small Car Under $21,000 - The Hyundai Accent won, followed in order by the Kia Rio5, Honda Civic Sedan, Chevrolet Sonic Sedan, Nissan Versa Sedan, Fiat 500 and Scion iQ. I voted in this category and pegged the Accent. Great handling, nice engine and lots of features even though it was the least expensive in the class.
Small Car Over $21,000 - Hyundai Elantra, followed by the Ford Ford Focus, Subaru Impreza and Volkswagen Beetle. I suspect the overall Car of the Year is going to come down to Accent vs. Elantra.
Family Car Under $30,000 - Kia Optima, followed by the Volkswagen Passat TDI, Toyota Camry, Mazda5, Chevrolet Orlando and Chrysler 200. I drove this category and while the Optima is a sweet ride, I wouldn't hesitate to recommend any of these vehicles as candidates for test-drives. I figured the Passat would win since journalists traditionally love diesels. I also thought the Orlando would do better than it did; it's a very nice, well-done car.
Family Car Over $30,000 - Kia Optima Hybrid, followed by the Hyundai Sonata Hybrid, Chevrolet Volt, Dodge Charger, Mini Countryman and Toyota Prius V. This is where you can stumble when you're faced with such wide categories: how do you compare a Dodge Charger to a Mini to a Volt? It comes down to assessing each vehicle on its merits and how well it does what it's supposed to do, but it's still very difficult.
Luxury Car - Mercedes-Benz C350 4Matic, followed by the Chrysler 300C, Acura TL, Infiniti M35h, Lexus CT200h and Buick LaCrosse eAssist. Amazing how many luxury cars are now adding electric motors.
Sports/Performance Under $50,000 - Hyundai Veloster, then Volkswagen Jetta GLI, Kia Optima SX, Mercedes-Benz C-Class Coupe, Honda Civic Si Coupe, Buick Regal GS and Dodge Charger SRT8. This was the shocker of the event: that the Veloster topped such high-powered hardware. It's a sporty little driver but I thought the GLI should have taken it. I also thought the Charger should have been rated much higher, especially given how many people praised its performance.
Sports/Performance Over $50,000 - BMW 1 M Coupe, followed by the Porsche Cayman R, Mercedes-Benz CLS-Class, Chrysler 300 SRT8, Hyundai Genesis R-Spec and Chevrolet Camaro Convertible. The 1 M made my knees go weak when I drove it, it's that good, but from all I've read, it's only going to be made for one year in very limited quantities. Why are we testing a car that may already be sold out and never built again?
Prestige Car Over $75,000 - Mercedes-Benz S-Class 350 BlueTEC, then the BMW 6 Series Cabriolet and Jaguar XKR-S. That diesel in the Mercedes could give cream a run for smoothness. I want that nasty, snarly Jaguar with all my heart and soul, though. I normally get bored pretty quickly with track driving, but I could have taken that car around it all day.
SUV/CUV Under $35,000 - Dodge Journey, then the Jeep Compass and Jeep Wrangler. Yes, you read that right: Chrysler was going home with hardware no matter what. That said, the wrong vehicle took the prize. The Wrangler is the best it has ever been, with a great engine, smoother ride, great interior and same awesome off-road capability. Too many people penalized it because it's a hard-core off-roader, but that's exactly the point they didn't get. And who on earth voted for a Compass that was optioned to twenty-nine thousand dollars?
SUV/CUV $35,000-$60,000 - Volkswagen Touareg TDI, followed by the Range Rover Evoque, BMW X1, Ford Explorer and Dodge Durango. I've never had a thing for the Touareg, which I find bloated and uncomfortable (Tiguan rules!), but its engine is nice. I thought it would be the Evoque and then the X1.
SUV/CUV Over $60,000 - BMW X3, then the Mercedes-Benz M-Class and Jeep Grand Cherokee SRT8. I voted in this class and felt the Jeep had it. This is why I don't bet heavily on horse races.
My final guess? I think that next February, the envelope will go to the Hyundai Accent and Dodge Journey. But I've definitely been wrong before.